Laura Pappano has an article in the syndicated Hechinger Report entitled “Students want hands-on training in the work of democracy. Colleges are answering.” It is mainly about the growth of undergraduate majors in public policy, which often originate in policy schools that traditionally served graduate-level professional students.
In the article, I say:
The focus on experiential learning appeals to today’s students, who tend to be “anxious about whether what they’re studying is going to get them a job, … And public policy seems pretty concrete, like you could work in state government.” Many young people right now are “very alienated from national politics. That’s “going to turn some of them, I think very wisely, to state and local politics [which] they may have been overlooking.”
Public policy majors are growing and spreading. Pappano writes, “Jodi Sandfort, dean of the Evans School of Public Policy & Governance at the University of Washington, whose public service and policy major started last year, said eight students graduated with it last spring — and 118 applied to the major this fall.”
It so happens that I visited the Evans School last week. While I was there, I made an appearance in a large undergraduate course. I acknowledged that federal civil service is only one form of public service. But I added that few young people have been interested in federal jobs during this century, even those who vote to expand federal programs. This is an anomaly: many young people who supported FDR, JFK or LBJ also aspired to work in Washington, and many did. But in ’08, when I asked college students who supported Obama whether they wanted to work for the executive branch, almost none said they were considering it. Nor did students flock to Washington to work for the expanded government led by Joe Biden.
I realize that many students would not want to work for the Trump Administration (although some do), but I invited the University of Washington students to imagine that a 2028 presidential candidate proposes to fill many of the 400,000 federal jobs that have been lost under Trump by hiring idealistic newcomers. Would they follow a generational call to rebuild and renew the civil service?
The other two programs that Pappanno describes are based in the University of Wisconsin’s LaFollette School and in the Olin College of Engineering. I am privileged to be friends with LaFollette’s Amber Wichowsky and Olin’s Erhardt Graeff (both mentioned in the article), each of whom took a summer institute with me. So this feels like a network.
Undergraduate-level public policy can be compared to Civic Thought curricula, which are often more historical and humanities-based and concerned with a “tradition”; Politics, Philosophy, and Economics (PPE), which is often more contemporary and concerned with questions of political economy; and Civic Studies, which addresses the question “What should we do?” in contrast to the question, “What should the policy be?” In Civic Studies, social movements and voluntary associations are often more prominent than constitutions and governmental institutions.
All of the above are growing these days. I’ve also made a case that Black Studies is a form of Civic Studies. The differences among them are interesting, but a thousand flowers should bloom.
See also a generational call to rebuild; is Black Studies Civic Studies?